Liz Cheney: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(updating about the end of her congressional career and the reason for it)
mNo edit summary
 
(40 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{subpages}}
{{subpages}}
{{TOC|right}}
{{Image|Us-rep-liz-cheney-meets-with-1st-lt-chris-rosso-b8f9cb-1024.jpg|right|350px|U.S. Rep. Liz Cheney meeting with a missile combat crew in a launch control center on the F.E. Warren Air Force Base missile complex in 2017.}}
'''Elizabeth L. ("Liz") Cheney''' (1966-) is an attorney and [[U.S. Republican Party]] activist, who is the daughter of [[Dick Cheney]] and [[Lynne Cheney]]. She is assisting her father with his memoirs, and is active in [[neoconservatism|neoconservative]] groups such as [[Keep America Safe]], and political warfare against the Obama Administration to defend the Bush-Cheney legacy. She is also a member of the International Board of Visitors at the University of Wyoming, and chairman of the board of the [[Institute for the Study of War]].


She is affiliated with her father's political approach, and appeals to the hard-line [[national security conservatism]] part of the [[Republican base]].  
'''Elizabeth L. ("Liz") Cheney''' (1966-) is an attorney and a former [[Republican Party (United States)]] activist, who is the daughter of [[Dick Cheney]] and was the U.S. congressional representative for Wyoming's at-large district from 2017 to 2023. Cheney is affiliated with her father's political stances.  In fall of 2023, Cheney will become a professor at the University of Virginia's Center for Politics.<ref>[https://www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2023/03/01/liz-cheney-university-virginia-professor/8681677704114/ Liz Cheney joins University of Virginia as a professor] on UPI.com 3-1-2023.</ref>


After the [[January 6 U.S. Capitol riot]], in 2022 Liz Cheney acted as vice-chair of the "Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol" which condemned [[Donald Trump]]s activities leading up to, and during, the attack.  For her participation, she as censored by the Republican party and lost her seat as congressional representative from Wyoming in late 2022.  She wrote the following iconic statement in the introduction to the committee's report:
Before the [[January 6 U.S. Capitol riot]], Liz Cheney was in the third leadership position of the Republican party in the [[U.S. House of Representatives]].  But after the riot (which occurred in early 2021), Liz Cheney acted as vice-chair of the "Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol" which condemned [[Donald Trump]]'s activities leading up to, and during, the attack.  For her participation in the House committee, she was censored by the national Republican party leadership and lost her seat as congressional representative from Wyoming in late 2022.  She was also ejected from the Wyoming state Republican party, but remained unapologetic for her choices.  She wrote the following iconic statement in the introduction to the House committee's report:


<poem>
<poem style="border: 2px solid #d6d2c5; background-color: #f9f4e6; padding: 1em; width: 70%">
Among the most shameful findings from our hearings was this: President Trump sat in the dining room off the Oval Office watching the violent riot at the Capitol on television.  For hours, he would not issue a public statement instructing his supporters to disperse and leave the Capitol, despite urgent please from his White House staff and dozens of others to do so.  Members of hi family, his White House lawyers, virtually all those around him knew that this simple act was critical.  For hours, he would not do.  During this time, law enforcement agents were attacked and seriously injured, the Capitol was invaded, the electoral count was halted, and the lives of those in the Capitol were put at risk.  In addition to being unlawful and described in this report, this was an utter moral failure--and a clear dereliction of duty.  Evidence of this can be seen in the testimony of his White House Counsel and several other White House witnesses.  ''No man who would behave that way at that moment in time can ever serve in any position of authority in our nation again.  He is unfit for any office.''
Among the most shameful findings from our hearings was this: President Trump sat in the dining room off the Oval Office watching the violent riot at the Capitol on television.  For hours, he would not issue a public statement instructing his supporters to disperse and leave the Capitol, despite urgent pleas from his White House staff and dozens of others to do so.  Members of his family, his White House lawyers, virtually all those around him knew that this simple act was critical.  For hours, he would not do it.  During this time, law enforcement agents were attacked and seriously injured, the Capitol was invaded, the electoral count was halted, and the lives of those in the Capitol were put at risk.  In addition to being unlawful as described in this report, this was an utter moral failure--and a clear dereliction of duty.  Evidence of this can be seen in the testimony of his White House Counsel and several other White House witnesses.  ''No man who would behave that way at that moment in time can ever serve in any position of authority in our nation again.  He is unfit for any office.''<ref name=Jan6Rept />
</poem>
</poem>
See the Wikipedia article [[Wikipedia:Liz_Cheney|Liz Cheney]] for more details.
{{TOC|right}}
==Stance opposing gay marriage==
Liz Cheney's sister Mary is openly gay and married with kids.  Since Liz Cheney's political stance since she ran for office in Wyoming has been "anti-gay-marriage", this appears to have been a point of contention between the sisters.  Liz' father Dick Cheney, on the other hand, took a libertarian ''laissez faire'' approach to the issue of gay marriage.  Liz Cheney's more hard-line policy is, one may reasonably assume, taken to satisfy the mainstream views of her constituency in Wyoming.


==Early career==
==Early career==
From 1988 to 1993, she worked on aid programs for Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union at the [[U.S. Department of State]] and at the [[Agency for International Development]] (AID). Her assignments included duty at the [[U.S. Embassy to Hungary]], as interim AID to [[Poland]], as Desk Officer for [[China]],  Special Assistant to the Deputy Secretary of State, and as Special Assistant to the Assistant AID Administrator for Asia and the Near East.  
From 1988 to 1993, she worked on aid programs for Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union at the [[U.S. Department of State]] and at the [[Agency for International Development]] (AID). Her assignments included duty at the [[U.S. Embassy to Hungary]], as interim AID to [[Poland]], as Desk Officer for [[People's Republic of China|China]],  Special Assistant to the Deputy Secretary of State, and as Special Assistant to the Assistant AID Administrator for Asia and the Near East.  


She then  practiced law at White & Case LLP in the area of international project finance from 1996 to 1999. From 1999 to 2002 she served on assignment with the International Finance Corporation, part of the [[World Bank]], where she provided legal advice on investing in the [[Middle East]] and [[Central Asia]].
She then  practiced law at White & Case LLP in the area of international project finance from 1996 to 1999. From 1999 to 2002 she served on assignment with the International Finance Corporation, part of the [[World Bank]], where she provided legal advice on investing in the [[Middle East]] and [[Central Asia]].
Line 25: Line 29:
  | url = http://www.newsweek.com/id/234930/output/print}}</ref>  
  | url = http://www.newsweek.com/id/234930/output/print}}</ref>  


She received praise, however, from  [[Edward Walker]], [[Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs]] at the end of the Clinton administration and former  president of the [[Middle East Institute]].
She received praise, however, from  [[Edward Walker]], Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs at the end of the Clinton administration and former  president of the [[Middle East Institute]].
<blockquote>Liz is a little different, obviously, because of the name. But the name doesn't bother anybody I know, simply because she did her job ... She could have been a disaster, given her father, given the fact that she knew all the players, she could have run roughshod [over career Foreign Service officers.] But she didn't.<ref name=NYT2005-05-31>{{citation
<blockquote>Liz is a little different, obviously, because of the name. But the name doesn't bother anybody I know, simply because she did her job ... She could have been a disaster, given her father, given the fact that she knew all the players, she could have run roughshod [over career Foreign Service officers.] But she didn't.<ref name=NYT2005-05-31>{{citation
  | date = 31 May 2005
  | date = 31 May 2005
Line 32: Line 36:
  | url = http://www.nytimes.com/2005/05/31/politics/31cheney.html?_r=1&pagewanted=print}}</ref></blockquote>
  | url = http://www.nytimes.com/2005/05/31/politics/31cheney.html?_r=1&pagewanted=print}}</ref></blockquote>


In the second term, according to [[Michael Isikoff]] and Michael Hirsh of ''Newsweek'', "she upset some more moderate political appointees by pressing hard to use government money for regime change in Syria and Iran. According to several former colleagues who would speak about her activities only on condition of anonymity, Cheney began acting more as an appendage of her father's office, at a time when administration policy was trending toward a more diplomatic approach." [[Robert Dreyfuss]], at the ''[[American Prospect]]'', reported "Liz Cheney, who exercises enormous power inside the State Department, has secured millions of dollars to support opposition elements in both countries, and she has met with Syria's version of [[Ahmed Chalabi]], a discredited businessman from Virginia named [[Farid al-Ghadry]]."<ref>{{citation
In the second term, according to [[Michael Isikoff]] and Michael Hirsh of ''Newsweek'', "she upset some more moderate political appointees by pressing hard to use government money for regime change in Syria and Iran. According to several former colleagues who would speak about her activities only on condition of anonymity, Cheney began acting more as an appendage of her father's office, at a time when administration policy was trending toward a more diplomatic approach." [[Robert Dreyfuss]], at the ''[[American Prospect]]'', reported "Liz Cheney, who exercises enormous power inside the State Department, has secured millions of dollars to support opposition elements in both countries, and she has met with Syria's version of Ahmed Chalabi, a discredited businessman from Virginia named [[Farid al-Ghadry]]."<ref>{{citation
   | url = http://www.prospect.org/cs/articles?articleId=11423
   | url = http://www.prospect.org/cs/articles?articleId=11423
  | journal = [[American Prospect]]
  | journal = [[American Prospect]]
Line 47: Line 51:


==Early Obama administration==
==Early Obama administration==
After her father gave a 21 May 2009 speech criticizing the [[Obama Administration]] for rejecting the [[intelligence interrogation, U.S., George W. Bush Administration|interrogation programs]] of the Bush Administration,<ref name=WaPo2009-05-21>{{citation
After her father gave a 21 May 2009 speech criticizing the [[Obama Administration]] for rejecting the intelligence interrogation|interrogation programs]] of the Bush Administration,<ref name=WaPo2009-05-21>{{citation
  | title = Cheney Defends Use of Harsh Interrogation Methods in Speech to AEI
  | title = Cheney Defends Use of Harsh Interrogation Methods in Speech to AEI
  | journal = Washington Post  
  | journal = Washington Post  
Line 65: Line 69:
  | url = http://dyn.politico.com/printstory.cfm?uuid=4AC619CC-18FE-70B2-A867172D25E92262}}</ref>  
  | url = http://dyn.politico.com/printstory.cfm?uuid=4AC619CC-18FE-70B2-A867172D25E92262}}</ref>  


Writing for the Thinkprogress blog of the liberal [[Center for American Progress]], Matt Duss described it as linked to the [[Foreign Policy Initiative]], an "attempt to reboot and rebrand the neoconservative [[Project for the New American Century]] (PNAC)."<ref>{{citation
Writing for the Thinkprogress blog of the liberal Center for American Progress, Matt Duss described it as linked to the [[Foreign Policy Initiative]], an "attempt to reboot and rebrand the neoconservative Project for the New American Century (PNAC)."<ref>{{citation
  | title = The Foreign Policy Keep America Project For A Safe New American Century Initiative  
  | title = The Foreign Policy Keep America Project For A Safe New American Century Initiative  
  | url = http://wonkroom.thinkprogress.org/2009/10/14/the-foreign-policy-keep-america-project-for-a-safe-new-american-century-initiative/
  | url = http://wonkroom.thinkprogress.org/2009/10/14/the-foreign-policy-keep-america-project-for-a-safe-new-american-century-initiative/
  | author = Matt Duss
  | author = Matt Duss
  | date = 14 October 2009
  | date = 14 October 2009
  | publisher = [[Center for American Progress]]}}</ref> He suggested this group will "essentially function as the street-fighting arm of the more 'serious', policy-oriented FPI."
  | publisher = Center for American Progress}}</ref> He suggested this group will "essentially function as the street-fighting arm of the more 'serious', policy-oriented FPI."


Its mission statement is phrased in political terms.<blockquote>America’s interests are challenged by an authoritarian China, a resurgent Russia, and dictators in our own hemisphere who ally themselves with our adversaries. Amidst the great challenges to America’s security and prosperity, the current administration too often seems uncertain, wishful, irresolute, and unwilling to stand up for America, our allies and our interests...By turning away from the policies that have kept us safe, by treating terrorism as a law enforcement matter, giving foreign terrorists the same rights as American citizens, launching investigations of CIA agents, cutting defense spending, breaking faith with our allies and attempting to appease our adversaries, the current administration is weakening the nation, and making it more difficult for us to defend our security and our interests.<ref>{{citation
Its mission statement is phrased in political terms.<blockquote>America’s interests are challenged by an authoritarian China, a resurgent Russia, and dictators in our own hemisphere who ally themselves with our adversaries. Amidst the great challenges to America’s security and prosperity, the current administration too often seems uncertain, wishful, irresolute, and unwilling to stand up for America, our allies and our interests...By turning away from the policies that have kept us safe, by treating terrorism as a law enforcement matter, giving foreign terrorists the same rights as American citizens, launching investigations of CIA agents, cutting defense spending, breaking faith with our allies and attempting to appease our adversaries, the current administration is weakening the nation, and making it more difficult for us to defend our security and our interests.<ref>{{citation
Line 79: Line 83:


==Middle East==
==Middle East==
On 6 June 2010, she said, on ABC News, that "(Israel's enemies) want to destroy the [[state of Israel]], and they are supported in that by the countries [[Iran]], [[Syria]][ and, now, it looks like [[Turkey]] as well...The prime minister of Turkey has stood up and said [[Hamas]] is not a terrorist organization. The Turks themselves have allied themselves with Iran and Syria." Referring to the Israeli raid on ships headed to the [[Gaza Strip]],  she said Turkey, usually considered a key U.S. ally, has decided against the United States.<ref>{{citation
On 6 June 2010, she said, on ABC News, that "(Israel's enemies) want to destroy the [[state of Israel]], and they are supported in that by the countries Iran, [[Syria]][ and, now, it looks like [[Turkey]] as well...The prime minister of Turkey has stood up and said [[Hamas]] is not a terrorist organization. The Turks themselves have allied themselves with Iran and Syria." Referring to the Israeli raid on ships headed to the [[Gaza Strip]],  she said Turkey, usually considered a key U.S. ally, has decided against the United States.<ref>{{citation
  | url = http://voices.washingtonpost.com/44/2010/06/liz-cheney-turkey-is-siding-wi.html?hpid=topnews
  | url = http://voices.washingtonpost.com/44/2010/06/liz-cheney-turkey-is-siding-wi.html?hpid=topnews
  | date = 6 June 2010
  | date = 6 June 2010
Line 85: Line 89:
  | title = Liz Cheney: Turkey is siding with our enemies}}</ref>
  | title = Liz Cheney: Turkey is siding with our enemies}}</ref>


==Future directions==
Isikoff  and Hirsh quoted Republican strategist [[Vin Weber]] as saying that she appeals to the <blockquote>"[[Sarah Palin]] constituency," but she has more intellectual credibility. "Nobody says about Liz" what they do about Palin, he says. Whether any of this is good for the Republican Party is anybody's guess. But at least a few moderate Republicans note—with some trepidation—that Palin may have a rival, and Dick Cheney may have an heir.<ref name=Newsweek2010-03-12 /></blockquote>
==Education==
*Bachelor's degree, Colorado College, 1988
*Law degree, [[University of Chicago]], 1996
==References==
==References==
<references>
<references>
</references>
 
<ref name=Jan6Rept>
[https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GPO-J6-REPORT/pdf/GPO-J6-REPORT.pdf Final Report] by the ''Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol'', Dec. 22, 2022, 117th Congress Second Session, House Report 117-663
</ref>
 
</references>[[Category:Suggestion Bot Tag]]

Latest revision as of 16:00, 12 September 2024

This article is developing and not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.
U.S. Rep. Liz Cheney meeting with a missile combat crew in a launch control center on the F.E. Warren Air Force Base missile complex in 2017.

Elizabeth L. ("Liz") Cheney (1966-) is an attorney and a former Republican Party (United States) activist, who is the daughter of Dick Cheney and was the U.S. congressional representative for Wyoming's at-large district from 2017 to 2023. Cheney is affiliated with her father's political stances. In fall of 2023, Cheney will become a professor at the University of Virginia's Center for Politics.[1]

Before the January 6 U.S. Capitol riot, Liz Cheney was in the third leadership position of the Republican party in the U.S. House of Representatives. But after the riot (which occurred in early 2021), Liz Cheney acted as vice-chair of the "Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol" which condemned Donald Trump's activities leading up to, and during, the attack. For her participation in the House committee, she was censored by the national Republican party leadership and lost her seat as congressional representative from Wyoming in late 2022. She was also ejected from the Wyoming state Republican party, but remained unapologetic for her choices. She wrote the following iconic statement in the introduction to the House committee's report:

Among the most shameful findings from our hearings was this: President Trump sat in the dining room off the Oval Office watching the violent riot at the Capitol on television. For hours, he would not issue a public statement instructing his supporters to disperse and leave the Capitol, despite urgent pleas from his White House staff and dozens of others to do so. Members of his family, his White House lawyers, virtually all those around him knew that this simple act was critical. For hours, he would not do it. During this time, law enforcement agents were attacked and seriously injured, the Capitol was invaded, the electoral count was halted, and the lives of those in the Capitol were put at risk. In addition to being unlawful as described in this report, this was an utter moral failure--and a clear dereliction of duty. Evidence of this can be seen in the testimony of his White House Counsel and several other White House witnesses. No man who would behave that way at that moment in time can ever serve in any position of authority in our nation again. He is unfit for any office.[2]

See the Wikipedia article Liz Cheney for more details.

Stance opposing gay marriage

Liz Cheney's sister Mary is openly gay and married with kids. Since Liz Cheney's political stance since she ran for office in Wyoming has been "anti-gay-marriage", this appears to have been a point of contention between the sisters. Liz' father Dick Cheney, on the other hand, took a libertarian laissez faire approach to the issue of gay marriage. Liz Cheney's more hard-line policy is, one may reasonably assume, taken to satisfy the mainstream views of her constituency in Wyoming.

Early career

From 1988 to 1993, she worked on aid programs for Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union at the U.S. Department of State and at the Agency for International Development (AID). Her assignments included duty at the U.S. Embassy to Hungary, as interim AID to Poland, as Desk Officer for China, Special Assistant to the Deputy Secretary of State, and as Special Assistant to the Assistant AID Administrator for Asia and the Near East.

She then practiced law at White & Case LLP in the area of international project finance from 1996 to 1999. From 1999 to 2002 she served on assignment with the International Finance Corporation, part of the World Bank, where she provided legal advice on investing in the Middle East and Central Asia.

For the 2000 and 2004 United States presidential elections, she managed vice presidential debate preparation.

George W. Bush Administration

In the first George W. Bush Administration, she was Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs, in the U.S. State Department under Colin Powell from 2002 to 2004. She was responsible for the establishment of the $300 million Middle East Partnership Initiative to support political, economic and educational reform and the empowerment of women in the Middle East. Perceived as an agent of the Vice President, according to Lawrence Wilkerson, Powell's chief of staff said, "She came across to me as ... pushing her weight around. She knew who her daddy was." [3]

She received praise, however, from Edward Walker, Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs at the end of the Clinton administration and former president of the Middle East Institute.

Liz is a little different, obviously, because of the name. But the name doesn't bother anybody I know, simply because she did her job ... She could have been a disaster, given her father, given the fact that she knew all the players, she could have run roughshod [over career Foreign Service officers.] But she didn't.[4]

In the second term, according to Michael Isikoff and Michael Hirsh of Newsweek, "she upset some more moderate political appointees by pressing hard to use government money for regime change in Syria and Iran. According to several former colleagues who would speak about her activities only on condition of anonymity, Cheney began acting more as an appendage of her father's office, at a time when administration policy was trending toward a more diplomatic approach." Robert Dreyfuss, at the American Prospect, reported "Liz Cheney, who exercises enormous power inside the State Department, has secured millions of dollars to support opposition elements in both countries, and she has met with Syria's version of Ahmed Chalabi, a discredited businessman from Virginia named Farid al-Ghadry."[5]

After leaving to give birth, she then joined the presidential primary campaign of Fred Thompson.

In a Washingon Post op-ed in 2007, she criticized Nancy Pelosi's suggestions for diplomatic engagement with Syria regarding the Middle East peace process, due to Syria's suspected involvement with assassinations in Lebanon. She called, instead, for the "(UN) Security Council [to] also hold Syria accountable for its ongoing violations of existing resolutions. The U.S. government should implement all remaining elements of the Syria Accountability Act and launch an aggressive effort to empower the Syrian opposition. European governments should demonstrate that they value justice over profit and impose financial and travel sanctions on Syria's leaders. [6]

Early Obama administration

After her father gave a 21 May 2009 speech criticizing the Obama Administration for rejecting the intelligence interrogation|interrogation programs]] of the Bush Administration,[7] she appeared on 12 television interviews, in 10 days, as an analyst of his position.[8]

Keep America Safe

For more information, see: Keep America Safe.

When she announced the formation of Keep America Safe in October 2009, she described the motivation as "The policies being proposed by the Obama administration are so radical across the board,” Whether you’re a Republican or a Democrat, you want the nation to be strong and so many steps this president is taking are making the nation weaker.”[9]

Writing for the Thinkprogress blog of the liberal Center for American Progress, Matt Duss described it as linked to the Foreign Policy Initiative, an "attempt to reboot and rebrand the neoconservative Project for the New American Century (PNAC)."[10] He suggested this group will "essentially function as the street-fighting arm of the more 'serious', policy-oriented FPI."

Its mission statement is phrased in political terms.

America’s interests are challenged by an authoritarian China, a resurgent Russia, and dictators in our own hemisphere who ally themselves with our adversaries. Amidst the great challenges to America’s security and prosperity, the current administration too often seems uncertain, wishful, irresolute, and unwilling to stand up for America, our allies and our interests...By turning away from the policies that have kept us safe, by treating terrorism as a law enforcement matter, giving foreign terrorists the same rights as American citizens, launching investigations of CIA agents, cutting defense spending, breaking faith with our allies and attempting to appease our adversaries, the current administration is weakening the nation, and making it more difficult for us to defend our security and our interests.[11]

Politico said

But its spirit is very much the Cheneys’. The former vice president assumed a high profile role last spring publicly contesting the Obama administration’s move to bring its interrogation policy in line with international law – and defending his own legacy. More recently, he’s faded into the background as Liz Cheney, deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs in the Bush years, emerges as the most visible defender of that administration’s foreign policy and the most vocal critic of Obama’s departures from it.

Middle East

On 6 June 2010, she said, on ABC News, that "(Israel's enemies) want to destroy the state of Israel, and they are supported in that by the countries Iran, Syria[ and, now, it looks like Turkey as well...The prime minister of Turkey has stood up and said Hamas is not a terrorist organization. The Turks themselves have allied themselves with Iran and Syria." Referring to the Israeli raid on ships headed to the Gaza Strip, she said Turkey, usually considered a key U.S. ally, has decided against the United States.[12]

References

  1. Liz Cheney joins University of Virginia as a professor on UPI.com 3-1-2023.
  2. Final Report by the Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol, Dec. 22, 2022, 117th Congress Second Session, House Report 117-663
  3. Michael Isikoff and Michael Hirsh (12 March 2010), "Palin With a Pedigree", Newsweek
  4. Todd S. Purdum (31 May 2005), "Weaned on Politics, Cheney Daughters Find a Place at the Table", New York Times
  5. Richard Dreyfuss (17 April 2006), American Prospect
  6. Liz Cheney (12 April 2007), "The Truth About Syria", Washington Post
  7. "Cheney Defends Use of Harsh Interrogation Methods in Speech to AEI", Washington Post
  8. Steve Benen (22 May 2009), "Nepotism Reigns", Washington Monthly
  9. Ben Smith (13 October 2009), "Liz Cheney takes on 'radical' W.H.", Politico (magazine)
  10. Matt Duss (14 October 2009), The Foreign Policy Keep America Project For A Safe New American Century Initiative, Center for American Progress
  11. Mission Statement, Keep America Safe
  12. "Liz Cheney: Turkey is siding with our enemies", Washington Post, 6 June 2010